Posted by: Dr Churchill | March 4, 2015

A Few Good Books: Life Together, The Cost of Discipleship, and Ethics, by Dietrich Bonhoeffer


As Adolf Hitler and the Nazis seduced a nation, bullied a continent, and attempted to exterminate the Jews of Europe, involving the whole world in their conflagration — a small number of dissidents worked to dismantle the Third Reich from the inside. One of these was Dietrich Bonhoeffer—a pastor and author. In this New York Times best-selling biography, Eric Metaxas takes both strands of Bonhoeffer’s life—the theologian and the spy—and draws them together to tell a searing story of incredible moral courage in the face of monstrous evil. Metaxas presents the fullest accounting of Bonhoeffer’s heart-wrenching decision to leave the safe haven of America to return to Hitler’s Germany, and sheds new light on Bonhoeffer’s involvement in the famous Valkyrie plot and in “Operation 7,” the effort to smuggle Jews into neutral Switzerland. “Bonhoeffer is the story of a life framed by a passion for truth and a commitment to justice on behalf of those who face implacable evil.  It’s a beautifully crafted biography.

“When Christ calls a man, he bids him to come and die.”

Dietrich Bonhoeffer wrote those words in his pivotal volume aptly titled “The Cost of Discipleship” which was first published in 1937 at the height of the rise of Nazism in Germany and he was absolutely prophetic about the common and the personal future that was to befall him and all the peoples of this earth.

Eight years later, on April 9, 1945, he answered Christ’s bidding and was executed by the Nazis at the Flossenburg concentration camp for his active rebellion in showing Christian Compassion and willingly sharing the fate of all the other victims of the German Concentration camps. He spoke clearly and articulately from the pulpit of the Confessor against the plight and the disappearance into the gas ovens of the Jews, of the Gypsies, of the strangers, the infirm, the invalids, the homosexuals, the communists, and socialists and all those different and diffident to the Nazi ideology.

And because of his vocal and ethical opposition — he was assassinated under the premise of conspiring to assassinate Adolf Hitler just a few days before Hitler committed suicide.

He was such a  thorn in the side of the Nazis that Hitler himself ordered Bonhoeffer to be killed just days before the end and when already the Russians were marching into Berlin itself.

And in a show of incredible strength Bonhoeffer’s last words on the gallows, appropriate to a Christian facing death, and divinely inspired — were totally full of Hope and Grace:

“This is the end of this journey … Yet for me is the beginning of life.”

In Bonhoeffer’s life we see a guide for a new generation of Christians, who are facing similarly difficult choices in their Lives and who are unacquainted with the history of Bonhoeffer or the victories in his Life as seen through his biography written by Eberhard Bethge — Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s closest friend.

And today Eric Metaxas offers a new biography of Bonhoeffer that is well written, well paced, and very insightful, especially regarding the theological, spiritual, and ethical evolution Bonhoeffer experienced in his conflict with the Nazis, which consumed his short but glorious life.

Dietrich Bonhoeffer was one of eight children born to Karl and Paula Bonhoeffer, and the youngest of five boys. He was the scion of illustrious families on both his paternal and maternal sides. His father Karl’s ancestors included prominent politicians and scientists. Karl himself was chair of the department of psychology at the University of Berlin–in effect, the leading psychologist of Germany. His mother Paula’s family included military leaders and theologians, including her grandfather, the prominent liberal church historian Karl August von Hase, and her father Karl Alfred, the erstwhile chaplain to Kaiser Wilhelm II.

Bonhoeffer followed in the footsteps of his von Hase ancestors, studying at Tubingen before achieving a double doctorate in theology at Berlin. Following his studies in Berlin, Bonhoeffer did a year of postgraduate work at Union Theological Seminary of New York, where he attended and taught Sunday school at Abyssinian Baptist Church in Harlem, then under the able leadership of Dr. Adam Clayton Powell Sr. Bonhoeffer was unimpressed by Union’s scholarship, but his involvement with Abyssinian gave him a deep love for “Negro spirituals” and important insights into how segregation damages both minorities and the majorities who oppress them.

Adolf Hitler and the Nazis came to power in 1933, when Bonhoeffer was just 27 years old. From the get-go, the Nazis attempted to subvert and control every traditional institution in Germany, including the German Evangelical (or Lutheran) Church. This attempted subversion drew Bonhoeffer into the opposition to Hitler that would eventually cost him his life. The struggle would also radicalize him in numerous ways. He increasingly realized that being a good German and being a good Christian were not coterminous. He increasingly began to practice a free-church ecclesiology in the midst of a state-church nation. And he increasingly realized that passivity in the face of evil was complicity with evil.

Most of Bonhoeffer’s work in the 1930s and 40s was professorial and pastoral. He helped found the Confessing Church, which was formed to oppose the Nazification of the state church. He helped found and lead the Confessing Church’s underground seminary at Finkenwalde. And throughout this time, he wrote what have become classics in theology and spiritual formation: Life Together, The Cost of Discipleship, and Ethics (which he completed toward the end of his life).

But all along, he was drawn increasingly into the conspiracy against Hitler. Bonhoeffer’s social class and family were deeply involved in this struggle. His older brother and two brothers-in-law were also executed for their involvement in the conspiracy against Hitler. Interestingly, they undertook this conspiracy from within the government and military, not outside of it.

At one point, when Bonhoeffer was about to be drafted into the Army, his family friends arranged for him to work for the Abwehr, or Military Intelligence. To many of his Confessing Church comrades, it appeared that Bonhoeffer had sold out. In reality, this position saved Bonhoeffer from military service and allowed him to continue pastoral work under the guise of doing assignments for the Abwehr.

On July 20, 1944, General Claus von Stauffenberg placed an explosive device under a table at a meeting with Hitler. The explosion killed several people, although Hitler lived, scathed but otherwise unharmed. Bonhoeffer was already in prison, although his role in this conspiracy wouldn’t become known for some time. Indeed, at one point, his uncle, General Paul von Hase, was able to get him special accommodations in the military prison just outside of Berlin.

With the failure of Stauffenberg’s bomb, however, the plot unraveled. Several thousand people were arrested, often because they were family members of conspirators, and several hundred were executed. The conspirators were aristocrats, military leaders, and civil servants–the traditional leaders of pre-war Germany. Why had they tolerated Hitler for so long?

They had been working against him from the beginning, but Hitler’s foreign policy and military successes made him very popular, and thus very difficult to work against.

Bonhoeffer had seen this difficulty nearly from the beginning. In a sense, he was a prophet who foresaw where Hitler’s regime would lead Germany, and counseled more radical action than conservative German’s traditional leaders–religious, military, or civil — could tolerate, until of course it was still late.

He, and they, paid for their dereliction with their lives.




If I have made much of Bonhoeffer’s involvement with the plot against Hitler, it is only because this is the most well-known thing about him. But Bonhoeffer reveals the layers of theology, spirituality, politics, and commitment that characterized his life.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: